Get A Quote

Building Trusted Relationships since 1982.

Benchmark Insurance is an independent agency that provides personally tailored insurance programs for businesses, individuals, and families in Central Ohio.

Headquartered in Westerville, Benchmark Insurance represents over 50 regional and national carriers to meet each client’s need for business insurance and employee benefits as well as life, health, auto and home insurance and retirement.

Dedicated to the community and to the integrity of the insurance profession, Benchmark Insurance actively participates in the Westerville Chamber of Commerce, the Columbus Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors, the Columbus Association of Health Underwriters, the Independent Insurance Agents of Ohio, and the Professional Insurance Agents Association of Ohio.

Our Agency

Our History

Realizing the need for an insurance agency that could not only provide coverage solutions for all types of insurance but also exceed service expectations for all clients, the founding partners of Benchmark Insurance opened its doors in 1982.

Today Benchmark's management team is continuing in the footsteps of the early guiding principle of building and maintaining a trusted relationship with all of our clients. One of the most distinctive ways Benchmark has accomplished this goal is by providing excellent administration of and creative solutions for employee benefits, commercial and personal insurance. It is our passion for excellence that has made Benchmark a recognized leader in Central Ohio.